• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

the blog of a bear

this is where a bear will post stuff.

open source software

the demise of qwitter: put into perspective by a well spoken blind individual.

September 20, 2011 by stickbear 4 Comments

Hello all;
All of you may have heard about the demise of the
qwitter
project developed and maintained by
christopher
If not. I’ll simply quote the
qwitter_hg
twitter accounts last post.

Qwitter Mercurial: Q: Closing up shop, it’s been fun.: 13 hours ago 9/19/2011 11:08:07 AM Qwitter Client

after reading that, I got curious and poked around Q’s timeline and the thoughts that ran through my head were mixed.
I was composing in my head a response I was going to put up here, outlining my thoughts and views, but
JonathanMosen
did a much better job of it then I could ever do. So I’ll simply quote his ressitation who’s original can be found
over here.

Billy Joel once said, “I once believed in causes too, and had my pointless point of view, but life when on no matter who was wrong or right”. I was mindful of this as I saw the considerable volume of tweets exchanged over the apparent halt to development of the Qwitter client, the Twitter client for Windows designed specifically for blind people. I say apparent, because this is in my recollection the third time such a threat has been made, so I suppose only time will tell if this one is real or not. Initially, I felt compelled to comment, then I decided there was no point, and now finally, I’ve felt moved to write an extended post about this subject because I think the conduct of a number of people in the latest Twitter drama represents a pattern that is all too typical in the on-line blind community.
Although I have been using Twitter since 2007, I actually was a late adopter of the Qwitter client, beginning to use it in around November of 2009. My reason for this was because I felt uncomfortable with the aggressive online behaviour of its lead developer. A friend of mine convinced me that it was appropriate to separate the behaviour of the developer from the quality of the application, and there’s absolutely no doubt that the software is first class. It is a feature-rich, efficient means of interacting with Twitter. Without Qwitter, I am sure much fewer blind people would be using Twitter so regularly. The award given to Chris by ACB this year recognises all of this, and that recognition is richly deserved.
I have, however, remained very disappointed by the extraordinary rudeness, even contempt, that Chris has shown to many users who have made suggestions or come to him for advice. I am mindful that I am making these comments with around 20 more years on the planet than him, and in this case I think that does make a difference. I hope that if Chris is unfortunate enough to be able to review some of his tweets in 20 years time, he will do so with genuine regret. What makes our world so diverse and interesting, is that we all have different strengths and weaknesses. Some people can write code, others conceptualise great user interfaces, others struggle with very basic computer concepts that just come naturally to some. Abrupt, rude, confrontational replies, many of which give the impression that the program’s author is somehow superior to or better than his fellow blind people are hardly going to remain unremarked upon.
Developing software is of course a very different skill from supporting it. Chris is obviously superb at the former. With a bit more good will towards people, I’m very confident the Qwitter Support account could have had a large number of volunteers, and Chris could have politely directed users to that account. We can wish that users would RTFM all we want, some simply will not, it is the reality of software development, and nothing is going to change that. Nor does the fact that the software is free make it any more acceptable to treat end users with rudeness.
Chris is, of course, absolutely right that there is a high proportion of blind Twitter users who are unemployed, may have difficulty getting out and about due to financial or transportation issues, and who therefore have plenty of time to generate Twitter drama. We do have a very high unemployment rate. Just as with sighted people, there are those who have never tried to find a job, those who in the current climate have become demoralised and have given up, those who spend hours every day looking for that big break. We seldom know each other’s stories, and it is sad when we choose to make very personal, sweeping assumptions. We do tend to sew what we reap. If we dish out confrontation on Twitter, chances are very high that confrontation will come right back at us. And it has been rather like watching a school bully crying when one little kid finally plucks up the courage to hit back, to see the lead Qwitter developer complaining when some of the hurt he has caused others comes back to him.
Does that make the behaviour of those who’ve responded in that way right or justified? Of course not. The best response to confrontation is often no response at all. Various Twitter characters in the blind community who’ve come and gone, have thrived on the fact that they know which buttons to push to get a reaction. Stop responding to them, and they’d have become bored and gone away long ago.
Then there is of course what we in New Zealand call the tall poppy syndrome. There is no doubt that Chris has considerable talent. In the blind community, we are good at building people up, to tear them down. Confrontational behaviour notwithstanding, there are some people who have sought to make his life a misery, almost as if they resent what he has been able to achieve. More than that, they are jealous of it.
Developing an app such as Qwitter obviously involves a very significant commitment of time. It has not completely been a labour of love, however. I haven’t taken the time to go back and do the sums, but I know I’ve personally donated at least US$100 to Qwitter, and that many others have donated what they can. I don’t regret doing so for a moment, nor do I expect that donations have created any kind of contract, expressed or implied, that Qwitter’s development would continue indefinitely. I raise this to simply point out that while a few users may have been vexatious, some provoked, some not, the project hasn’t been totally without its financial compensation.
Whether a piece of software is commercial or not, there is no guarantee that its development will continue forever. There are many examples of software used by a large number of people where development has simply stopped. Microsoft Money is a case in point. The issue I have is the point in the development cycle at which Qwitter development is apparently ceasing. It is in beta right now. Because it is beta software, there are problems, as one would expect. Does Chris have a legal obligation of any kind to tidy up the critical bugs? Of course not. He can walk away whenever he likes, and apparently has. The question is one of moral obligation, and of his personal brand. Would I be as willing to support any future project, commercial or otherwise, by a developer who leaves a user base in the lurch like this? No, I’d think twice, because I don’t believe that this is an ethical way to treat people. Anything we do online impacts on our personal brand. If we’re abusive, people make a mental note of that. If we walk away because a few people, again some provoked, some not, have been abusive, even though the majority of us have been supportive with our praise and with our wallets, then that leaves a sour taste and a reputation that is hard to recover.
Whether you volunteer or not should not make a difference to one’s conduct. I’ve volunteered over many years for a range of positions, including leading New Zealand’s blindness consumer organisation which would be the equivalent of NFB and ACB, serving on various committees, and of course managing Internet radio projects like Mushroom FM. In all of those cases, the work involved has been considerable. It’s involved a huge investment of time and effort. And there are times when circumstances require you to walk away. But if you have to do that, you should do so by tidying up as many of the loose ends as you possibly can.
I don’t begrudge for one second the fact that Chris may have concluded that he has better things to do with his life, that it’s just not rewarding anymore. If you are copping a lot of abuse, especially when you’re younger, it’s hard to shrug that off, and easy to say, why on earth am I bothering. My only issue is that I hope he will recognise how his own conduct as contributed in part to some of the grief that has come his way, and that to protect his reputation, he at least get Qwitter 5 to a production release and make it clear that that’s the end of the project. If he does not, then I fear the bad taste the half finished Qwitter project has left in so many mouths will continue to haunt him. That would be a pity when he is clearly such a gifted young man.
As for the rest of us, maybe there’s a good number of us who might like to think twice before joining in the flame war. Most of us in the blind community are online in such a way that our interactions are filtered to us through a mechanical sounding speech synthesiser. It is easy for us to forget that the tweet we send in a quick burst of anger or sarcasm may be the one that tips a real human being with feelings over the edge. We don’t know what else is going on in their lives, how they may be feeling. If we showed a little more on-line empathy, just empathy in general really, imagine how much of a peaceful place the online world would be.
I urge Chris to reconsider wrapping up the project in this stage in the cycle, but regardless, thank him sincerely for a very significant contribution to bringing blind people around the world closer together, and assisting us to interact with equal efficiency with our sighted peers.

A few final thoughts.
Is qwitter the only accessible client on windows?
No, it’s not.
Their are others like
TWInbox
that can do the basics.
Yes, not as feature rich, but qwitter’s development cycle ending isn’t the end all of twitter for the blind community.
Would I, like Jonathan, think twice about supporting another project, weather free or paid put out by this individual if he doesn’t at least take qwitter 5.0 to a stable release before shutting down?
Yes, I honestly would reconsider ever supporting future projects developed by him because of the way he handled qwitter and it’s closure.
I understand open source, but leaving those in the blind community with extremely buggy code because your being a nazi and don’t want to at least head for a final release before giving up is insane, and rediculous.
What are others thoughts and views.
I’d love to here what you have to say on this, spoken in a constructive, adult manner.
No childish bashing.
Constructive critisisms and pieceful debate are the name of the game.
See you on the comment boards.

Filed Under: accessibility, computers, feelings, internet, open source software, response, technology, thought

Qualcomm Hands Off Eudora to Mozilla

October 13, 2006 by stickbear Leave a Comment

Good morning everyone.
this
article
from
beta news.com
entitled:
Qualcomm Hands Off Eudora to Mozilla
is interesting.
I will post the article in it’s entirety below.
enjoy.
Qualcomm Hands Off Eudora to Mozilla

By
Nate Mook
and
Scott M. Fulton, III,
BetaNews

October 11, 2006, 2:57 PM

Qualcomm on Wednesday joined up with the Mozilla Foundation to announce it is transitioning
Eudora
into an open source e-mail client that will be based upon
Thunderbird.
In turn, all future versions of Eudora will be free and Qualcomm will discontinue the current paid client.

Although it may seem like Eudora is simply abandoning its e-mail software, which has a small but strong following of loyal users, the company claims the
Thunderbird-based client will retain “Eudora’s uniquely rich feature set and productivity enhancements.”
The first release of the open source client is expected in early 2007, at which point Eudora will cease selling the product commercially. In the meantime,
Eudora will be priced at $19.95 USD and come with three incidents of support in a six month period. Until today, Qualcomm sold Eudora versions for a suggested
retail price of as high as $49.95 USD.

Current Eudora users can choose to keep running the ad-supported version indefinitely after upgrading to version 7.1 for Windows and 6.2.4 for Mac OS X,
released last week but announced only today. Qualcomm says it will stop displaying advertisements in the client sometime early next year.

“Qualcomm has decided not to remain in the email market because it is not in alignment with the core business or strategic goals,” the company said. “By
moving Eudora to an open source product, Qualcomm can exit the Eudora business while still supporting Eudora users and advancing the Eudora e-mail client
at a faster pace than before, through the power of the open source development community.”

“We’re pleased to welcome Eudora and its millions of users to the world of open source,” said Frank Hecker, executive director of the Mozilla Foundation.
“This effort should further enrich the Thunderbird technology platform and provide users of both products with an even richer email experience.”

In recent months, reviewers continued to give Eudora the performance edge for use with enterprise e-mail, compared against Thunderbird (though not against
Microsoft Outlook). However, in practice, some have noted Eudora has suffered limited performance problems with recent versions, prompting in at least one case suggestions that users (in this case, students) try Thunderbird instead.

Filed Under: e-mail, internet, open source software, technology

>Qualcomm Hands Off Eudora to Mozilla

October 13, 2006 by stickbear Leave a Comment

>Good morning everyone.
this
article
from
beta news.com
entitled:
Qualcomm Hands Off Eudora to Mozilla
is interesting.
I will post the article in it’s entirety below.
enjoy.
Qualcomm Hands Off Eudora to Mozilla

By
Nate Mook
and
Scott M. Fulton, III,
BetaNews

October 11, 2006, 2:57 PM

Qualcomm on Wednesday joined up with the Mozilla Foundation to announce it is transitioning
Eudora
into an open source e-mail client that will be based upon
Thunderbird.
In turn, all future versions of Eudora will be free and Qualcomm will discontinue the current paid client.

Although it may seem like Eudora is simply abandoning its e-mail software, which has a small but strong following of loyal users, the company claims the
Thunderbird-based client will retain “Eudora’s uniquely rich feature set and productivity enhancements.”
The first release of the open source client is expected in early 2007, at which point Eudora will cease selling the product commercially. In the meantime,
Eudora will be priced at $19.95 USD and come with three incidents of support in a six month period. Until today, Qualcomm sold Eudora versions for a suggested
retail price of as high as $49.95 USD.

Current Eudora users can choose to keep running the ad-supported version indefinitely after upgrading to version 7.1 for Windows and 6.2.4 for Mac OS X,
released last week but announced only today. Qualcomm says it will stop displaying advertisements in the client sometime early next year.

“Qualcomm has decided not to remain in the email market because it is not in alignment with the core business or strategic goals,” the company said. “By
moving Eudora to an open source product, Qualcomm can exit the Eudora business while still supporting Eudora users and advancing the Eudora e-mail client
at a faster pace than before, through the power of the open source development community.”

“We’re pleased to welcome Eudora and its millions of users to the world of open source,” said Frank Hecker, executive director of the Mozilla Foundation.
“This effort should further enrich the Thunderbird technology platform and provide users of both products with an even richer email experience.”

In recent months, reviewers continued to give Eudora the performance edge for use with enterprise e-mail, compared against Thunderbird (though not against
Microsoft Outlook). However, in practice, some have noted Eudora has suffered limited performance problems with recent versions, prompting in at least one case suggestions that users (in this case, students) try Thunderbird instead.

Filed Under: e-mail, internet, open source software, technology

Primary Sidebar

Subscribe to Podcast

Apple PodcastsGoogle PodcastsAndroidby EmailRSS

my goodreads challenge!

2020 Reading Challenge

2020 Reading Challenge
Shane has read 2 books toward his goal of 40 books.
hide
2 of 40 (5%)
view books

my currently reading shelf

Shane's currently-reading book montage



Shane's favorite books »

Recent Posts

  • the Shane O Train archive for January 14, 2021.
  • the Shane O Train for January 7, 2021.
  • The Shane O Train from December 10, 2020.
  • this is what happens when bears break stuff.
  • did I break it?

Recent Comments

  • Steve on people seriously had the balls to whine about this app going free?
  • DM on they actually certified it.
  • stickbear on More on the lawsuit, a letter being sent around, and inaccessible forms, for serious?
  • Steve on More on the lawsuit, a letter being sent around, and inaccessible forms, for serious?
  • Tay on More on the lawsuit, a letter being sent around, and inaccessible forms, for serious?

Archives

  • January 2021
  • December 2020
  • November 2020
  • October 2020
  • September 2020
  • August 2020
  • July 2020
  • June 2020
  • May 2020
  • April 2020
  • March 2020
  • February 2020
  • January 2020
  • December 2019
  • November 2019
  • August 2014
  • June 2014
  • May 2014
  • March 2014
  • January 2014
  • October 2013
  • September 2013
  • June 2013
  • May 2013
  • April 2013
  • March 2013
  • February 2013
  • January 2013
  • December 2012
  • November 2012
  • October 2012
  • September 2012
  • August 2012
  • July 2012
  • June 2012
  • May 2012
  • April 2012
  • March 2012
  • February 2012
  • January 2012
  • December 2011
  • November 2011
  • October 2011
  • September 2011
  • August 2011
  • July 2011
  • June 2011
  • May 2011
  • April 2011
  • March 2011
  • February 2011
  • January 2011
  • December 2010
  • November 2010
  • October 2010
  • July 2010
  • June 2010
  • May 2010
  • March 2010
  • February 2010
  • January 2010
  • December 2009
  • October 2009
  • September 2009
  • August 2009
  • July 2009
  • June 2009
  • May 2009
  • April 2009
  • March 2009
  • February 2009
  • January 2009
  • December 2008
  • November 2008
  • October 2008
  • September 2008
  • February 2007
  • December 2006
  • October 2006
  • September 2006
  • August 2006
  • July 2006
  • January 2006
  • August 2005
  • July 2005
  • June 2005
  • May 2005
  • April 2005
  • March 2005
  • January 2005
  • December 2004
  • November 2004
  • October 2004
  • September 2004
  • August 2004
  • July 2004
  • June 2004
  • May 2004
  • January 2004

Categories

  • accessibility
  • ADBC
  • adult humor
  • amber
  • amusement
  • articles
  • audio posts
  • blog announcements
  • book reviews.
  • brain-vomit
  • Bryan Carver
  • cell phones
  • children
  • christianity
  • computers
  • court
  • crappily designed software
  • e-mail
  • facebook
  • feelings
  • Freedom Scientific
  • FSU stupid
  • general
  • general ranting
  • GPS
  • guideDogAdventures
  • hockey
  • humanware
  • humor
  • humour
  • interesting blogs
  • internet
  • iphone
  • josh
  • kerri
  • Leukemia
  • life
  • lists ftw
  • maple leafs
  • mojo radio
  • motherzilla
  • music
  • my braille note
  • my child
  • news
  • news articles
  • ODSP
  • open communication
  • open source software
  • opinion
  • other stuff
  • people needing a clue
  • personal
  • personal life
  • podcast
  • psycho-x-girlfriends
  • quiz's
  • radio show
  • raille note
  • random posts from random locations
  • random posts of random things
  • random shows
  • rantings
  • rants
  • relationship
  • relationships
  • response
  • reviewing my life
  • rose
  • school
  • security
  • selfish people
  • shane
  • skype
  • skype church service
  • special events
  • stuff that fails
  • stupid people
  • technology
  • tek savvy
  • testing
  • thought
  • threats
  • toronto
  • travel
  • trekker.
  • tv
  • Uncategorized
  • updates
  • useless stats
  • weird and slightly deranged
  • writings
  • WRMS fire
  • WRMS lawsuit
  • wtf

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

Copyright © 2021 · News Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in